A carved pediment inside the walls of Lafayette Cemetery No. 1 reads "Deutschen Presbyt. Gemeinde" and, beneath it, "Mai 1866." It belongs to the German Presbyterian Society Tomb, a 20-vault Gothic Revival tomb built for low-income German immigrants. This summer it was repointed, replastered and given a repaired roof and scupper. Several of its vaults were reopened so it can take burials again. The cemetery had been closed to the public for seven years, and this restored tomb shows what kind of place reopened on October 1. It is an active burial ground first. Visitors come second, and their ticket money helps keep the grounds in repair.
The gates on Washington Avenue now open to two groups. Families of the people interred there visit by appointment. Everyone else comes in with a guide from Save Our Cemeteries, which is now a department of the Preservation Resource Center of New Orleans. The City chose it as the only tour operator after a public bid. Every other part of the reopening follows from that setup.
Why the gates closed in 2019
Lafayette No. 1 was established in 1833, the same year the City of Lafayette was incorporated, on the block bounded by Washington, Sixth, Prytania and Coliseum. It is the oldest of the city's seven municipal cemeteries. For years before the closure, it also worked as a film set and tour stop, largely because of Anne Rice's "Interview with the Vampire."
In its September reporting, NOLA.com quoted Jessica Strawn, the City's acting superintendent of cemeteries, describing the grounds as having become "a bit of a circus." Sara Lowenburg, director of Save Our Cemeteries, told the paper that families sometimes paid respects at a loved one's grave while guides nearby reenacted movie scenes or told supernatural stories. The same article reports that the Tomb and Coping Owners' Association formed in 2019 after a visitor trying to look inside a tomb broke off a piece of it. That year the City closed the cemetery, partly for repairs and partly in response to concerns from families.
Burials continued throughout the closure, Strawn told NOLA.com. The cemetery never stopped working.
What changed behind the wall
According to NOLA.com, the City pulled up the broken asphalt paths and put down gravel walkways over a drainage liner. Dead magnolias were removed, the living ones were treated, and a structural engineer reviewed the foundation of the perimeter wall. Strawn said the work took two administrations and the pandemic, and that limited staffing, personnel changes and time spent researching families' concerns delayed the reopening. The City did not release the project's cost.
Responsibility splits along the property lines. Every tomb in Lafayette No. 1 is privately owned and maintained by its owners. The City handles the common areas, including walkways, walls, gates and lights. For years, the families' own work filled the gap between those two jobs. The owners' association at lafayettecemeteryno1.org records annual late-October family cleanup days during the closure. The first, on October 26, 2019, let families clean and prepare their plots ahead of All Saints' Day.
Who comes first now
The reopening puts the families' priorities into writing. In the City and PRC agreement, family visits, funerals, maintenance and cemetery operations all take priority over tours. Guides are trained to reroute or pause a tour to respect families who are present.
| Who | How they get in | What applies |
|---|---|---|
| Families of those interred | Appointment through the City's Division of Cemeteries, (504) 658-3781 | Family visits take priority over tours |
| Visitors and neighbors | Guided tour with Save Our Cemeteries only | Up to 16 guests per group, 75 to 90 minutes |
| Funerals and maintenance | City cemetery operations | Take priority over tours |
| Independent and ghost tours | Not permitted | Save Our Cemeteries is the sole operator |
"No ghost tours," Strawn told NOLA.com. PRC's plan rules out sensational, supernatural and entertainment-focused content and calls for historically vetted interpretation instead. NOLA.com also reported that Lowenburg said the cemetery will close to the public on All Saints' Day, Mother's Day, Father's Day and other days when families traditionally visit their tombs.
The City's own Division of Cemeteries page still labels Lafayette No. 1 "closed to the public," with the exception of guided tours and family appointments. Under the new arrangement, the gate is open only on those terms.
How the tour money returns to the tombs
The economics changed along with the access. In its September 21 announcement, PRC said the City will receive a share of tour revenue, and PRC will set aside part of its own proceeds for restoration and preservation at City-owned cemeteries, Lafayette No. 1 among them. NOLA.com reported the City's terms from its copy of the contract. The City takes 20% of revenue up to $150,000 and 27.5% of revenue above $350,000, and it will use that money for cemetery maintenance.
Under the old model, the crowds wore the place down and paid nothing toward fixing it. NOLA.com recounted that by 2005, the Los Angeles Times was reporting preservationists' complaints that the cemetery had been "trashed, trampled, spray-painted and otherwise defaced." Under the new model, a share of every ticket goes back into the walls, paths and tombs.
The German Presbyterian Society Tomb is the first visible result of that approach. PRC paid for its full restoration, and the work was done by Bayou Preservation and Nola Cemetery Renewal. The Presbytery of South Louisiana owns the tomb and can now reopen it for burials for families in need. Save Our Cemeteries has restored more than 50 family and society tombs at Lafayette No. 1 since it was founded in 1974.
"This is an active burial ground and a sacred place of memory for families and communities, and that must come first."
Sara Lowenburg, Director of Save Our Cemeteries, in PRC's September 21 announcement
That October 23 PRC essay by Lowenburg also explains why the upkeep never ends. New Orleans has no naturally occurring stone, so the tombs were built from local brick and lime mortar and plaster made partly from oyster shell, materials that need ongoing care in this damp climate. Repairs like the work on the German Presbyterian tomb will be needed again and again, and the tour revenue is set up to help cover them.
Booking a morning inside
For a Garden District household, the cemetery is a short walk away. Commander's Palace sits directly across Washington Avenue. Here is how a visit works for you or for out-of-town guests:
- Book with Save Our Cemeteries. The Lafayette Cemetery No. 1 tour page lists the address as 1400 Washington Ave. and links to the booking calendar. If a time isn't available online, the booking system directs callers to (504) 525-3377.
- Plan around the price. Tickets cost $30 for adults and $15 for children 6 to 12. Children under 6 go free.
- Go in the morning. NOLA.com reported that the 75- and 90-minute tours run in the mornings for groups of up to 16.
- Expect pauses. Guides will reroute or stop when a family is visiting or a funeral is underway.
- Families use a separate line. Relatives of people interred there can call the Division of Cemeteries at (504) 658-3781 to set up an appointment.
For family history research, the City notes that Fred and Heath Hatfield transcribed the cemetery's inscriptions and tablets in 1996, and their database is online at lafayettecemetery1.com. PRC's plan also includes up to 10 free tours each year for New Orleans public school groups, plus discounts for educational groups, veterans' groups and local nonprofits.
The tomb with "Mai 1866" on its pediment now stands restored inside the cemetery's walls, and its vaults can once again take burials.
At Elizabeth McNulty, we think the history of a Garden District home includes the blocks around it. The tombs behind the wall on Washington Avenue, and the people working to keep them standing, are part of that history. If you own a home near Lafayette No. 1 and want to talk through its place in the neighborhood's story, we welcome you to Request a Private Consultation.